Daredevil is Catholic (so far)

Superman (although born pagan and raised Methodist) has a very Calvinist ethos. Dude is SAVED, right? Once and for all.* Superman's heroism is predestined. But not Daredevil. His friends, and even he himself, aren't always sure whether he is doing the right thing.

He and the villain he hopes to bring down have pretty much exactly the same goals. And rather similar motivations. And their techniques vary only in (important) details.

Daredevil is working out his salvation in fear and trembling. Daredevil is Catholic.

It's always problematic to endorse a show before they've stopped making it, because you just never know where they're going to take it. It's especially dangerous to pronounce that a show is "Catholic" or even that its values are in the right place. But, hey, I like to live dangerously.

I really enjoyed this show. And I appreciated seeing Catholic themes and struggles fairly portrayed on mainstream TV.

Comic writer Frank Miller, on whose "Born Again" story arc the Netflix show Marvel's Daredevil is based, has said, "I figured Daredevil must be Catholic because only a Catholic could be both an attorney and a vigilante." (via)

He's no Man of Steel, impervious to pain or injury. We see him beaten, broken. He is seriously hurt every time he goes out to fight bad guys. But he keeps getting up and getting back in the fight.

He's no millionaire playboy with a basement full of ridiculously awesome technology at his disposal. He has to work for a living. By day, he upholds the law, trusting a jury to make the right call. By night, he's the judge and jury, punishing bad guys with his own two hands. (Literally. He eschews guns. And the fact that he doesn't kill any of the bad guys seems to be mostly on purpose.)

Even his superpowers are born of weakness. He has extraordinarily heightened senses of hearing, and smell, and kinesthetics, but only as a result of the car accident that robbed him of his sight.

Perhaps even more central to his life as a crime-fighter are the lessons young Matt learned from his father, a tenacious but troubled professional boxer. Battlin' Jack Murdoch was never knocked out. Beaten, yes, but always on his feet. Daredevil is the same way. Dude gets his Butt. Kicked. Every night. But he drags himself up again and keeps fighting through the pain.

Oh, and there's his faith.

Claire: On top of that, you can take an unbelievable amount of punishment without one damn complaint.
Matt: That last part's the Catholicism.

Religion and superheroes can be tough to sort out. Most of the well-known comic book superheroes have a religious affiliation, assigned to them by their (largely Jewish) creators. As a writer, if you want to know a character, and understand his motivations, you'd, of course, have to understand his faith.

But, for the vast majority of them, that faith is nothing more than back story.

Daredevil, throughout his long-running comic (which I haven't read), through multiple writers and reboots, in his movie (which I haven't seen), and now in this TV series (which I have seen), has consistently been a notable exception to the rule. His religion is a deep part of who he is.

Daredevil isn't, ya know, a GOOD Catholic, but he is a Catholic. In the opening scene of the Netflix show, it's clear that he doesn't understand how confession works. But he's there. And the priest DOES understand how confession works, so that's nice. That same priest features prominently throughout this first season. His advice is consistently empathetic and theologically sound.

Matt: I'm not seeking penance for what I've done, Father, I'm asking forgiveness for what I'm about to do.
Priest: That's not how this works.

Daredevil/Matt Murdoch has been a comic book character through many decades and many writers. It's my understanding that in that medium, he doesn't always live out Catholic moral teaching in his personal life. But THIS review is on the Netflix show. And in season one of this show, he does. There are multiple allusions by other characters to how Matt "does well with the ladies." But what that means precisely isn't confirmed by Matt or shown on screen. As far as we know from watching this show, he is a good Catholic boy.

Matt Murdoch spends this season in much the same state as Seeley Booth was when we met him in the first season of Bones. Both men have a deep sense of the Truth of Catholicism, and are searching for answers in religion to the difficult questions posed by their career choices.

Priest: It's all right, seal of confessional. Anything you said during the Sacrament of Penance stays between us. You could have killed ten people. I couldn't tell anyone.

Nine seasons later, it's clear that Booth isn't willing to move from a faith of ideas to one of actions. And it's clear that the writers of that show think that theology of the body doesn't apply to attractive people.

If every other show that's ever been on TV is any indication, Daredevil will go down the same way next season. And I will be sad. But, for THIS season anyway, Daredevil is Catholic.

* except for 2013's Man of Steel, directed by a guy who is awesome at making Batman movies but who doesn't seem to understand the character of Superman.

p.s. There is a scene of other non-married characters waking up together. There's no nudity, but there is some language. And a LOT of graphic violence. I had to employ the "hand over the gross part of the screen" many times, but that works for me. It is rated MA. I would recommend it for teens and adults.

And that's my honest opinion. But this is a sponsored post.

Have you seen Daredevil yet? What did you think?

You might also enjoy . . .

Bless Me Father, for I'm a Catholic on a TV Show

There's a Right Way and a Wrong Way to Fracture a Fairy Tale . . .

Maleficent vs Cinderella and the Heroes We Give Our Children